Good expectation of Allah, Ibn al-Qayyim argues, cannot be separated from action: the one who does good expects good from his Lord, while the one persisting in major sins and injustice is kept from it by the estrangement his wrongdoing brings (A044-3, A045-1). Reflected on properly, good expectation of Allah is good action itself (A048-3); where it leads to idleness and sin, it has become delusion (A086-1).
Written for The Cure and checked against the Arabic — not Ibn al-Qayyim’s words. Each claim rests on A044-3, A045-1, A048-3, A086-1.
Ibn al-Qayyim’s discussion
6 key passages
Ibn al-Qayyim’s text
Arabic ed. p. 48–49 · حسن الظن بالله هو حسن العمل نفسه
ومن تأمل هذا الموضع ٠ حق التأمل علِم أن حسن الظن بالله هو حسنُ العمل نفسه. فإنَ العبد إنما يحمله على حسن العمل حسنُ ظنه بربه أن يجازيه على أعماله» ويثيبه عليهاء ويتقبّلها منه. فالذي حمله على العمل حسنُ الظن» وكلما حسُن ظلّه حسُن عمله؛ وإلا فحسٌ الظن مع اتباع الهوى عجزء كما في الترمذي والمسند من حديث شدّاد بن أوس عن النبى كي أنّه قال: «الكيّس من دان نفسّه؛ وعمل لما بعد الموت. والعاجز من أتبع نفسّه هواهاء وتمثى على الله 6
English reference translation · short quotation
Whoever thoroughly contemplates over the aforementioned shall come to know that having good thoughts about Allah happens with performing good actions. …
The Disease and The Cure, tr. Osman Hamid (Hikmah Publications, 2020), p. 63.
Ibn al-Qayyim’s text
Arabic ed. p. 44–45 · حسن الظن بالربً إنما يكون مع طاعته
ولا ريب أن حسن الظن إنما يكون مع الإحسان» فإنٌ المحسن حسن الظن بربه أنه يجازيه؟ على إحسانه» ولا يخلف وعده؛ ويقبل توبته. وأما المسيء المصرّ على الكبائر والظلم والمخالفات؛ فإ وحشة المعاصي والظلم والإجرام تمنعه 0 من حسن الظن بربه ٠. وهذا موجود في الشاهدء فإنَ العبد الآبق المسيء الخارج عن طاعة سيده لا يحسن ]1/٠١[ الظن د:
English reference translation · short quotation
Undeniably, good thoughts rightfully occur when there are good actions. The good doer has adopted good thoughts about his Lord that He will reward him for his good, not betray His promise and accept his repentance. …
The Disease and The Cure, tr. Osman Hamid (Hikmah Publications, 2020), p. 59.
Ibn al-Qayyim’s text
Arabic ed. p. 45 · حسن الظن بالربً إنما يكون مع طاعته
English reference Hikmah edition, p. 59 (aligned match, under “A Good Thought About the Lord Can Only Happen With Obedience”). The translation is not reproduced here.
The defining subtlety in this matter is that hope and good thoughts are fulfilled through the appropriate means that have been set by the Perfect Wisdom of Allah in His legislation, capability, recompense and generosity. …
The Disease and The Cure, tr. Osman Hamid (Hikmah Publications, 2020), p. 97.
Ibn al-Qayyim’s text
Arabic ed. p. 49 · حسن الظن بالله هو حسن العمل نفسه
وبالجملة»؛ فحسن الظن إنّما يكون مع انعقاد أسباب النجاح. وأما مع انعقاد أسباب الهلاك» فلا يتأتى إحسان الظن.
English reference Hikmah edition, p. 63 (probable match, under “Good Thoughts About Allah Are Essential Alongside Perform ing Good Actions”). The translation is not reproduced here.
Ibn al-Qayyim’s text
Arabic ed. p. 86 · الفرق بين حسن الظنْ والغرور
فقد تبين الفرق بين حسن الظن والغرور» وأنّ حسن الظن إن حمل على العمل َ وحثّ عليه» وساق إليه» فهو صحيح. وإن دعا إلى البطالة والانهماك فى المعاصى» فهو غرور.
English reference Hikmah edition, p. 95 (aligned match, under “The Difference Between Good Thoughts and Delusion”). The translation is not reproduced here.
The book touches on this in 18 passages in all; the 6 above are the key ones. Arabic edition pages: 44, 45, 46, 48, 49, 50, 75, 86, 87.
Qur’an and Sunnah mentioned by Ibn al-Qayyim
Only references cited in this topic’s passages. Nothing has been added.
Hadith
Related topics
Hope in AllahMentioned together in 4 passages, on p. 75, p. 86, p. 87
Two topics are linked only when at least three passages of the book mention both, and those passages were read to confirm the connection is real. A link means the book discusses them together — not that one causes the other.